SUBSCRIBE
SUBSCRIBE
SLJ Blog Network +
  • 100 Scope Notes
  • A Fuse #8 Production
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • Heavy Medal: A Mock Newbery Blog
  • Teen Librarian Toolbox
  • The Classroom Bookshelf
  • The Yarn
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About/Contact
  • Book Discussion
  • Heavy Medal Mock
  • Process

December 17, 2009 by Nina Lindsay

Checking my list twice, or three times

December 17, 2009 by Nina Lindsay   2 comments

I’m trying to clean up on my re-reading in time for our Mock Newbery and the actual announcements…. 

Having now read Years of Dust thoroughly, I’m not sure I have much to add to the debate, except to respond to Jonathan when he says:

"I think the incorporation of Florence Owens Means (aka Migrant Mother) shows how Marrin has attempted, at least, to acknowledge American Indians.   He could have told the story of the Dust Bowl without any mention of American Indians–indeed, many have probably already done so–but he did not, and whether or not you think he successfully depicted their place in history and ecology, I think you have to acknowledge the effort."

I agree that Marrin’s attempted top acknowledge American Indians. I’m not sure I need to acknowledge his effort because it seems like a shoddy effort. The inclusion of the images of the Hopi Snake Dance seem odd to me. Except for the mention of Florence Owens Thompson (where stating her ethnicity sticks out–why does it matter there?), and a sidebar on p.110 about current times, no where else do we hear about how the Native Americans were affected by or responded to the Dust Bowl.  The Hopi Snake Dance pictures are provocatively "exotic," and it just makes me feel like Marrin needed some more exciting pictures that all those piles of dust. If he really wanted to tell about the Native Americans during the dust bowl (I’m not saying I find it necessary at all), he could have done better homework, and maybe wouldn’t have flubbed that final quote.

SCROLL TO KEEP READING THIS POST

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

The debate on Almost Astronauts seems to have circled round to where it started from, and I’m going to let it lie for a while. I’m looking forward to debating this one at our live Mock Newbery on January 10th. Whether it rises to the top of my list or not, I think the issues this book raises in its tone and presentation are important to discuss, and I thank Tanya Stone at least for the courage to write a risky book. 

I just quickly re-read The Great and Only Barnum to remind myself why it didn’t make my final discussion list, especially as it’s made YALSA’s nonfiction finalists list.  I do think this is a fabulous book, and know it will do well this year.  Fleming’s style is almost in direct opposite to Stone’s: you forget the author exists, and just feel that you are there experiencing the story.  This is often admirable; but here I actually wished for just a little more authorial voice. Barnum is such a controversial character, certainly some things warrant just a little comment, like the fact that Tom Thumb recalls he never had a childhood, or that Barnum’s statements for the African-American right to vote later in life reveal a possible change in character from his earliest days when he exhibited Joice Heth’s autopsy, or that the SPCA today has different views of the Barnum and Bailey show than it did in his time.   It’s the controversial nature of the subject that makes this story attractive. And Fleming’s text makes it accessible and engaging…but also leaves the narrative feeling not quite drawn out as much as it could be at moments. Still: this on my list of top picks for the year, and if I had a longer discussion list it would probably be there too. 

Taking home another four to re-read over our holiday furlough, and saving When You Reach Me for last. It’ll make my third go-round, but has had several months to settle…several months for the criticism to sink in and several months for me to have read some really strong contenders. 

Filed under: Uncategorized

SHARE:

Read or Leave Comments

About Nina Lindsay

Nina Lindsay is the Children's Services Coordinator at the Oakland Public Library, CA. She chaired the 2008 Newbery Committee, and served on the 2004 and 1998 committees. You can reach her at ninalindsay@gmail.com

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

January 2023

FREEWATER wins the Newbery Medal, live reactions from Heavy Medal bloggers

by Nina Lindsay

January 2023

Heavy Medal Mock Newbery Webcast Results

by Nina Lindsay

December 2022

Calling all Mock Newbery Enthusiasts: Join the 2023 Heavy Medal Award Committee

by Nina Lindsay

October 2022

Two More Titles: November Nomination Time

by Nina Lindsay

September 2022

85 Books to Consider: Mock Newbery Suggestions Updated

by Nina Lindsay

ADVERTISEMENT

SLJ Blog Network

100 Scope Notes

BLUE FLOATS AWAY Turns Two!

by Travis Jonker

A Fuse #8 Production

Review of the Day – Bear and Bird: The Picnic and Other Stories by Jarvis

by Betsy Bird

Good Comics for Kids

Review: Swim Team

by Esther Keller

Heavy Medal

March suggestions: early Mock Newbery possibilities

by Emily Mroczek-Bayci

Teen Librarian Toolbox

Write What You Know. Read What You Don’t, a guest post by Lauren Thoman

by Amanda MacGregor

The Classroom Bookshelf

The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving

by Erika Thulin Dawes

The Yarn

Jarrett and Jerome Pumphrey Try Something New

by Travis Jonker

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles on SLJ

Children’s Publishing World Reacts to Michaela Goade's History-Making Caldecott Medal, Rest of the YMA Winners

Ringing in the Newbery (and Caldecott): An awards-trivia smackdown with Betsy Bird and Travis Jonker

A Grateful Michaela Goade Makes Caldecott History

2021 Youth Media Awards Winners

Susan Cooper on her Wartime Childhood and How Writing Is "Fed by My Unconscious" | The Newbery at 100

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jonathan Hunt says

    December 18, 2009 at 7:03 am

    I’m going to retire from the YEARS OF DUST and ALMOST ASTRONAUT discussions, but even as I do so, my mind likewise turns to THE GREAT AND ONLY BARNUM and it seems to be growing in stature the more I glance back through it. I sort of disagree with Nina’s quibbles. I like the understated authorial voice here and I think Fleming navigates controversial territory better than Marrin or Stone–and navigates it for a younger audience than those authors, too.

    My mind is also drawn to the other YALSA Nonfiction finalist that has only been mentioned in passing here: WRITTEN IN BONE by Sally Walker. I’d also like to note that this book snagged a Newbery Honor in the recent Austin Public Library mock Newbery (WHEN YOU REACH ME won with ALL THE BROKEN PIECES and CALPURNIA TATE as the other honor books). I think the opening note to the reader strikes the right balance that some feel has eluded Peck and Marrin: Walker will not include photographs nor discussions of Indian remains in this archaelogical book, and yet the decision hardly means she would promote an empty land myth. But I’ll leave that for Nina and Debbie to judge.

  2. Nina says

    December 18, 2009 at 1:47 pm

    Make no mistake: I like Fleming’s voice here too, and think she does a remarkable job. My quibbles are slight. If it had happened once, I probably wouldn’t have mentioned it, but there were just a small handful of places where I felt like she glanced over what could have been a very interesting examination of Barnum’s character.

ADVERTISEMENT

Archives

  • Other Mock Newbery Sites

    • Anderson’s Bookshops
    • For Those About to Mock
    • Good Reads Mock Newbery
    • Northport-East Northport PL
    • Rhode Island OLIS
  • Resources

    • Jen J's Starred Reviews Spreadsheet
    • Newbery Manual
    • Newbery Medal & Honor Books
    • Newbery Terms & Criteria
  • Follow This Blog

    Enter your email address below to receive notifications of new blog posts by email.

    This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

    This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

    Primary Sidebar

    • News & Features
    • Reviews+
    • Technology
    • School Libraries
    • Public Libraries
    • Age Level
    • Ideas
    • Blogs
    • Classroom
    • Diversity
    • People
    • Job Zone

    Reviews+

    • Book Lists
    • Best Books
    • Media
    • Reference
    • Series Made Simple
    • Tech
    • Review for SLJ
    • Review Submissions

    SLJ Blog Network

    • 100 Scope Notes
    • A Fuse #8 Production
    • Good Comics for Kids
    • Heavy Medal
    • Neverending Search
    • Teen Librarian Toolbox
    • The Classroom Bookshelf
    • The Yarn

    Resources

    • 2022 Youth Media Awards
    • The Newbery at 100: SLJ Celebrates the 100th Anniversary of the Award
    • Special Report | School Libraries 2021
    • Summer Reading 2021
    • Series Made Simple Spring 2021
    • SLJ Diverse Books Survey
    • Summer Programming Survey
    • Research
    • White Papers / Case Studies
    • School Librarian of the Year
    • Mathical Book Prize Collection Development Awards
    • Librarian/Teacher Collaboration Award

    Events & PD

    • In-Person Events
    • Online Courses
    • Virtual Events
    • Webcasts
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Subscribe
    • Media Inquiries
    • Newsletter Sign Up
    • Content Submissions
    • Data Privacy
    • Terms of Use
    • Terms of Sale
    • FAQs
    • Diversity Policy
    • Careers at MSI


    COPYRIGHT © 2023


    COPYRIGHT © 2023