A Passel of Poetry
We’ve already discussed a couple of poetry books (SWIRL BY SWIRL, NEVER FORGOTTEN) and a couple of verse novels (INSIDE OUT & BACK AGAIN and EDDIE’S WAR) and I think they stand the best chance of Newbery recognition in their respective genres, but there is actually a rich, diverse field of books published this year to choose from.
POETRY BOOKS
EMMA DILEMMA by Kristine O’Connell George . . . A charming collection of poems about being a big sister. Three starred reviews, SLJ list.
EVERY THING ON IT by Shel Silverstein . . . This posthumous collection will undoubtedly be the biggest hit with children, but the quality of poems is uneven, the drawings provide the punch line for many of them, and they do not tend to reward multiple readings with new insights and appreciation. Three stars, SLJ list.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
THE GREAT MIGRATION by Eloise Greenfield . . . We’ve already discussed the Great Migration in the context of HEART AND SOUL, but Greenfield’s poetry cycle also honors the movement of African Americans from the rural South to the urban North. Four stars.
ROOTS AND BLUES by Arnold Adoff . . . Adoff’s signature shaped speech poetry is not the most accessible style, but this book is a perfect marriage of form and subject. Four stars, Kirkus and SLJ lists. It’s a nice companion book for BLUES JOURNEY by Walter Dean Myers, and speaking of Myers . . .
WE ARE AMERICA by Walter Dean Myers . . . One of our most decorated children’s poets, Myers’s latest poem is a patriotic paean that celebrates America even as it acknowledges her shortcomings. Two stars, Kirkus list.
VERSE NOVELS
ADDIE ON THE INSIDE by James Howe . . . This one has a lot of things working against it–it’s a sequel, it’s a school story, it’s political–but it’s definitely worth a read. Two stars, SLJ list.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
HIDDEN by Helen Frost . . . Frost always creates these complicated forms and then writes really good verse novels. For me, the forms are so complicated that it’s hard for me to truly appreciate them in a literary sense. I do marvel at her skill, but in the same way that I marvel at the skill of a good maker of crossword puzzles. I had the same problem with MIRROR, MIRROR last year. One star, Kirkus list.
HURRICANE DANCERS by Margarita Engle . . . Since winning a Newbery Honor for SURRENDER TREE, Engle’s subsequent verse novels get mentioned regularly as Newbery possibilities, but it’s been a relatively buzz free year. One star.
PLANET MIDDLE SCHOOL by Nikki Grimes . . . BRONX MASQUERADE is one of my all-time favorites so I make a dilligent effort to read her stuff. This is another strong effort, but I don’t think it separates itself from this pack of verse novels, let alone the entire field. One star.
THE WATCH THAT ENDS THE NIGHT by Allan Wolf . . . This is probably the best verse novel of the year, but it’s size (400+ pages) and questions about its audience will make it difficult to build consensus around. Three stars, Horn Book list.
Filed under: Uncategorized
About Jonathan Hunt
Jonathan Hunt is the Coordinator of Library Media Services at the San Diego County Office of Education. He served on the 2006 Newbery committee, and has also judged the Caldecott Medal, the Printz Award, the Boston Globe-Horn Book Awards, and the Los Angeles Times Book Prize. You can reach him at hunt_yellow@yahoo.com
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
Your 2023 Caldecott Comment Card
Poems As Picture Books: Zetta Elliott Discusses the Upcoming A Song for Juneteenth
2023 ALA Youth Media Awards
A Conversation with Kendare Blake about BUFFY, THE NEXT GENERATION
The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving
ADVERTISEMENT
Sylvia Vardell has some video clips of Adoff, Greenfield, Grimes, and Sidman reading or discussing their recent work at NCTE.
http://poetryforchildren.blogspot.com/2011/11/ncte-2011-4-big-poetry-events.html
Hidden is the only one of this bunch that I’ve read, and I thought it was excellent. The complicated form just acted as a fun extra – it was the characters and sentence-level writing that made it stand out for me. The first part also has fantastic tension right from the first page.
I was also happy to find HIDDEN. I have a list of girls who will love it. Perfect for 6th grade girls who like to read but have trouble finishing books, who like drama and a dash of romance.
I thought that THE WATCH THAT ENDS THE NIGHT was a tour de force. I was astonished by the way the author could tell so many different stories–(there are twenty-five different points of view, with each character’s story having its own tensions and climaxes)–while building the cumulative tension and climax of the big-picture disaster. The quality of the verse is strong, and the different stories are told so skillfully that they’re easy to follow. I am not a big Titanic fan, and despised the movie, but this book is something else entirely. When all the stories drew together, and the ship sank, I was appalled and moved to tears.
I don’t think the fact that the book is 400 pages long should be considered a liability. And in this case, the page count is somewhat deceptive, as some of the pages contain short poems. Could the author have told the story faster, with fewer characters? Undoubtedly–but not without losing richness, complexity, and force.
And the book reads FAST. You feel the pull of it–you’re heading for that tragic climax as inexorably as the ship steams toward the iceberg. It’s a fantastic read.
I read about a third of THE WATCH THAT ENDS THE NIGHT, but had to put it down because of review deadlines. I plan to get back to it soon. I like what I have read so far, and I could easily jump on this Newbery bandwagon if it holds up. It has 76,000 words (which probably includes the extensive back matter). Even so, that’s 5,000 words less than MOON OVER MANIFEST or THE EVOLUTION OF CALPURNIA TATE and without the back matter it’s probably closer in size to THE GRAVEYARD BOOK (67,000) or HATTIE BIG SKY (70,000). So I do agree that the length is deceptive and that the book does read *very* quickly.
I think it’s primary audience would be grades 7-9, but motivated/precocious students in grades 4-6 would be fine with reading it, too, although it doesn’t look/feel like your typical juvenile book. If SURRENDER TREE can win a Newbery Honor, I see no reason why this one can’t either. Of all the books we’ve mentioned for the older end of the range, namely CHIME and BETWEEN SHADES OF GRAY, this is the one that I think I could actually get behind and place in my top three.
I started reading The Watch That Ends the Night at a restaurant and thought the first two poems so wonderful that I should put it away until I could concentrate on it properly. I haven’t found the right moment yet, but am looking forward to it.
I didn’t find Hidden very strong (particularly in development of plot and theme), but I know it has several strong supporters here. I look forward to hearing specifics about why you think this book is a Newbery contender, since most of the Goodreads reviews have given high marks more to the idea behind the book than the writing–what I think of as “reviewing the Wikipedia article” instead of the book. (Another example of “reviewing the Wikipedia article”–that is, I think, what quite a few people thought was going on with those of us who like Jefferson’s Sons. Hope we were able to convince you otherwise.)
The hidden-messages idea worked better, I thought, in the author’s Diamond Willow (although I liked that book even less). They were easier to read, added more to the story, and, I felt, made for less of a sort of artificial manipulation of the text that I sensed in Hidden. Some of the sentences seemed very awkward, ostensibly to allow for the hidden-message feature.
LOVED The Watch that Ends the Night, and kept sharing things I learned from it with my family. It deserves an award.
I, too, loved THE WATCH THAT END THE NIGHT, and I’ve had a few of my 8th graders read it and like it, so it definitely works for its intended audience and the award’s audience. I like what Anonymous said about it reading fast. Giving a voice to the iceberg was a stroke of genius, offering an almost primordial sense of fate…and doom.
Great list! Personally, among the ones I have read, I find Roots and Blues the most intriguing.
Booklist Editors’ Choice came out today, and the following poetry books and verse novels made their list: SWIRL BY SWIRL, NEVER FORGOTTEN, INSIDE OUT & BACK AGAIN, NEVER FORGOTTEN, ROOTS AND BLUES, and THE WATCH THAT ENDS THE NIGHT. Here’s the complete tally (with only Bulletin Blue Ribbons to come on Jan 1) . . .
five lists
CHIME
HEART AND SOUL
four lists
SCORPIO RACES
BLINK & CAUTION
INSIDE OUT & BACK AGAIN
DRAWING FROM MEMORY
A MONSTER CALLS
BETWEEN SHADES OF GRAY
MOUSE & LION
ANYA’S GHOST
WONDERSTRUCK
three lists
BLACKOUT
CAN WE SAVE THE TIGER?
ORANI
DAUGHTER OF SMOKE & BONE
WHERE’S WALRUS
PRESS HERE
DEAD END IN NORVELT
AMELIA LOST
WHY WE BROKE UP
THE GIRL WHO CIRCUMNAVIGATED FAIRYLAND . . .
FLESH & BLOOD SO CHEAP
AROUND THE WORLD
OKAY FOR NOW
BOOTLEG
ME . . . JANE
LIFE: AN EXPLODED DIAGRAM
BALLOONS OVER BROADWAY
THE HOUSE BABA BUILT
ROOTS AND BLUES
PAPER COVERS ROCK
SWIRL BY SWIRL
two lists
WHITE CROW
HOW TO SAVE A LIFE
SMALL PERSONS WITH WINGS
BEAUTY QUEENS
GRANDPA GREEN
STAY WITH ME
TITANIC SINKS!
CHESHIRE CHEESE CAT
UNDERGROUND
A BALL FOR DAISY
BONE DOG
I WANT MY HAT BACK
NAAMAH AND THE ARK AT NIGHT
BREADCRUMBS
THE WATCH THAT ENDS THE NIGHT
AMERICA IS UNDER ATTACK
A NATION’S HOPE
Can you give us the link, please? Thanks.
http://ala-publishing.informz.net/ala-publishing/archives/archive_2008966.html
It’s fascinating to me how much of what’s on the Booklist list is nowhere else. I count 53 titles total and of those I think 26 have only been recognized by Booklist. That’s just about half! So this got me interested in how that ratio plays out on the other lists: Of the 30 books Horn Book recognized, only 7 are unique to their list. 28 of the 66 SLJ titles are unique; 15 of the 40 PW titles; and 70 (!) of the 108 Kirkus titles are unique. Those numbers are all over the board, but it’s kind of cool to see what a variety of things are considered best across the different journals. I also find it interesting (and the more I think about it, the more it makes sense to me) that the smaller the list, the less likely there will be outliers. In order from smallest list to largest: Horn Book has about 23% unique; PW has 37.5% unique; Booklist has 49% unique; SLJ has 42% unique; 65% of Kirkus is unique. Only Booklist and SLJ switch places in terms of percentages as the list numbers increase. Yea for fun with numbers! Also – I show Swirl by Swirl on 3 lists – Booklist, Horn Book and SLJ, but I have made mistakes in my spreadsheet before and this could be another!
Thanks
Jen, nope, the SWIRL BY SWIRL mistake was mine, and the division between nonfiction and picture book probably confused me. I’ve changed it above. I was really happy to see some of the Booklist titles finally make a list. NEVER FORGOTTEN got five starred reviews, but no list–until Booklist. THE GREAT MIGRATION had four. THE SILVER BOWL had three. So some of these unique titles got a fair amount of starred reviews, but were passed over by the other journals. You make a good point about the number of choices on a list. For example, SLJ and Kirkus probably have more books on their best of the year list than either Horn Book or Bulletin starred all year.
http://www.hbook.com/2011/12/blogs/calling-caldecott/the-great-migration/