“Best Books,” Mocks, and the Newbery Medal
This is the time of year that book review journals share their “best books of the year” lists. These are always fascinating, and significantly different from the lists of nominations we collect here on Heavy Medal. That makes perfect sense, since on we’re focusing specifically on Newbery Criteria on Heavy Medal, while the journals have their own guidelines for the lists (and these vary with the different publications). Still, it’s always interesting to compare.
So far I’ve seen four lists by the major journals: School Library Journal, Publishers Weekly, Horn Book, and Kirkus. As far as I can tell, Booklist and The Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books are not out yet. [update: Booklist‘s “Editors’ Choice” and BCCB’s “Blue Ribbon” lists are out!] I totaled up the four lists so far in order to compare to the titles we’ve looked at on Heavy Medal. I didn’t track every single title: I only added picture books and teen titles if they received a nomination on HM, for example. And tried to skip all of the Newbery-ineligible titles. Here are a few observations:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
13 books landed on at least three of the lists. Four of those received no nominations on Heavy Medal: one graphic novel (BORDERS), one picture book biography (NINA), one nonfiction (REVOLUTION IN OUR TIME) and one poetry collection (HELLO EARTH).
Title | Author | Total “Best Books” lists (out of 4 so far) | Heavy Medal Nominations |
BEATRYCE PROPHECY | Kate DiCamillo | 4 | 16 |
NINA | Traci Todd | 4 | 0 |
BLACK BOY JOY | Kwame Mbalia (ed) | 3 | 1 |
BORDERS | Thomas King | 3 | 0 |
FALLOUT | Steve Sheinkin | 3 | 5 |
GENIUS UNDER THE TABLE | Eugene Yelchin | 3 | 14 |
HELLO EARTH | Joyce Sidman | 3 | 0 |
LAST CUENTISTA | Donna Barba Higuera | 3 | 3 |
LEGEND OF AUNTIE PO | Shing Yin Khor | 3 | 2 |
MILO IMAGINES THE WORLD | Matt de la Peña | 3 | 5 |
REVOLUTION IN OUR TIME | Kekla Magoon | 3 | 0 |
TOO BRIGHT TOO SEE | Kyle Lukoff | 3 | 8 |
UNSPEAKABLE | Carole Boston Weatherford | 3 | 4 |
WATERCRESS | Andrea Wang | 3 | 6 |
This next list shows the 16 books that received the highest number of Heavy Medal nominations. Of these, four were not named on any of the Best of the Year lists so far: JUST LIKE THAT, LION OF MARS, A PLACE TO HANG THE MOON, and PITY PARTY.
Title | Author | Heavy Medal Nominations | Total “Best of” lists (4 so far) |
RED, WHITE, AND WHOLE | Rajani LaRocca | 19 | 1 |
BEATRYCE PROPHECY | Kate DiCamillo | 16 | 4 |
AMBER AND CLAY | Laura Amy Schlitz | 14 | 2 |
GENIUS UNDER THE TABLE | Eugene Yelchin | 14 | 3 |
JUST LIKE THAT | Gary Schmidt | 13 | 0 |
STARFISH | Lisa Fipps | 10 | 2 |
SHAPE OF THUNDER | Jasmine Warga | 9 | 1 |
LION OF MARS | Jennifer L. Holm | 8 | 0 |
PLACE TO HANG THE MOON | Kate Albus | 8 | 0 |
TOO BRIGHT TOO SEE | Kyle Lukoff | 8 | 3 |
WATERCRESS | Andrea Wang | 6 | 3 |
AMARI AND THE NIGHT BROTHERS | B.B. Alston | 5 | 1 |
DAVINCI’S CAT | Catherine Gilbert Murdock | 5 | 1 |
FALLOUT | Steve Sheinkin | 5 | 3 |
MILO IMAGINES THE WORLD | Matt de la Peña | 5 | 3 |
PITY PARTY | Kathleen Lane | 5 | 0 |
How has this played out in past years? Below is the list of Newbery and Honor books from the past three years, along with the number of Best Books lists they made and the number of Heavy Medal Nominations.
Most (but not all) Newbery titles also do well in the area of starred reviews (thanks once again to Jen J. for her handy spreadsheet of starred reviews that goes all the way back to 2011). There are more misses on the Heavy Medal column; most (but not all) of those are with books on the lower or higher edge of the age range.
Newbery Books | Award Year | Best Books Lists | Heavy Medal Nominations |
WHEN YOU TRAP A TIGER | 2021 | 5 | 11 (most noms: 15) |
ALL THIRTEEN | 2021 | 5 | 1 |
BOX | 2021 | 5 | 0 |
FIGHTING WORDS | 2021 | 6 | 11 |
WE DREAM OF SPACE | 2021 | 5 | 7 |
A WISH BEFORE DARK | 2021 | 1 | 5 |
NEW KID | 2020 | 4 | 20 (20) |
GENESIS BEGIN AGAIN | 2020 | 3 | 8 |
OTHER WORDS FOR HOME | 2020 | 5 | 7 |
SCARY STORIES FOR YOUNG FOXES | 2020 | 1 | 8 |
UNDEFEATED | 2020 | 5 | 0 |
HELLO UNIVERSE | 2019 | 4 | 7 (8) |
CROWN | 2019 | 4 | 0 |
LONG WAY DOWN | 2019 | 6 | 1 |
PIECING ME TOGETHER | 2019 | 4 | 3 |
It would be cool if we could look at all of this and come up with a numbers-based way to predict Newbery winners, but I’m afraid not. It’s still going to come down to the 15 individual Committee members and their year of exhaustive reading, intense discussion, and the casting of their final ballots.
Filed under: Book Discussion
About Steven Engelfried
Steven Engelfried retired from full-time library work a couple years ago and now works as a part-time Youth Librarian at the West Linn Public Library in Oregon. He served on the 2010 Newbery committee, chaired the 2013 Newbery Committee, and also served on the 2002 Caldecott committee. You can reach him at sengelfried@yahoo.com.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
Further Predictions! Everything That ISN’T Newbery/Caldecott 2025
Hilda and Twig | This Week’s Comics
The Seven Bills That Will Safeguard the Future of School Librarianship
Shakespeare, but Make it Queer!: Retelling a Classic Play and My Love/Hate Relationship with William Shakespeare, a guest post by Emma K. Ohland
Gayle Forman Visits The Yarn!
ADVERTISEMENT
Emily Mroczek-Bayci says
ohh all these statistics are so much fun!
NINA is a book I don’t even think I looked at this year. I better investigate it.
I’d also love to give a shout out to Betsy Bird’s non official but quite fun 31 days of lists where she does a different list every day of December. I always find some good, obscure reads on these. Today is books with a message! https://blogs.slj.com/afuse8production/2021/12/10/31-days-31-lists-2021-books-with-a-message/
Eric says
NINA is a brilliant (one could even say perfect) picturebook and I’d like to read thoughts on its potential for Newbery. Check Horn Book’s Calling Caldecott Blog next week for my extensive thoughts on its Caldecott potential.
Meredith BUrton says
I love how thorough this blog is in analyzing the lists and comparing. It has truly shocked me how Just Like That has been neglected by “Best of: lists. Is everyone just angry with Schmidt for his decision at the beginning of the book or something? It just doesn’t make sense as the writing, plot and characterization is very strong. Oh well. I am glad the book is receiving recognition here.
Thank you for this comprehensive analysis. I had never heard of Borders until it was mentioned here. I hope to one day read The Legend of Auntie Po as well. Maybe an audio adaptation will be produced.
Steven Engelfried says
I’m not sure about JUST LIKE THAT. I was thinking maybe the journals lean more towards authors and titles that might be less known to their readers…but Kate DiCamillo made 4 lists, so scrap that theory.
I haven’t read BORDERS yet either, but it sounds interesting. Amazon has a preview of several pages. The author lives in Canada, but appears to have US citizenship as well, so should be eligible.
Katrina says
So interesting! Although not 100% accurate—I nominated Undefeated, but you ruled it ineligible! 😆
Steven Engelfried says
We should have followed your lead, Katrina! My mistake, but I’m still glad it won the Honor that year…
Katrina says
Yes, the lesson is always listen to me! 😆 Seriously though, I’m so glad it got recognized too!